Is the Smith Machine a Joke?

Mindset comic · July 26, 2026 · 6 slides

The Smith machine is a valuable exercise tool because its fixed movement path reduces stability demands to focus load directly on targeted muscles. Built-in safety hooks allow solo lifters to safely push sets to failure without needing a spotter. It is best utilized for exercises like presses, rows, and shrugs rather than squatting movements, and weight used should be tracked against previous Smith machine sets rather than barbell weights.

The GainFrame mascot stands with arms crossed next to a loaded Smith machine, asking if the machine is actually a joke.
Is the Smith machine a joke?
The GainFrame mascot stands beside gym equipment, explaining that a fixed bar path maximizes load on target muscles by reducing the need to balance.
1. The fixed bar path is the feature Less balancing means more load on the muscle That is the whole point of a machine
The GainFrame mascot rests a hand on a empty Smith machine frame, demonstrating how built-in hooks let lifters safely train to failure without a spotter.
2. It is the safest way to push The hooks catch the bar with no spotter You can actually go to the edge
The GainFrame mascot reads a logbook while standing between a Smith machine and a barbell setup, advising lifters to only track progression against previous Smith machine performances.
3. Stop comparing the number Smith weight is not barbell weight Compare it to your last Smith set
The GainFrame mascot performs an overhead press marked with a green checkmark next to a squat attempt marked with a red X, illustrating that the Smith machine should be used for upper body pressing rather than traditional squats.
4. It is not a squat replacement The fixed path fights your hips on squats Use it for presses, rows and shrugs
The GainFrame mascot walks towards available equipment, emphasizing that utilizing an open Smith machine is better than waiting around for a squat rack.
5. Use it when the rack is taken A decent set beats waiting fifteen minutes The best machine is the free one

Like the comics? The app does the tracking.

GainFrame turns progress photos into body fat estimates, muscle scores, and honest trend lines — the stuff these comics keep nagging you about. Free to start on iOS.

Download GainFrame Free